90.9 WBUR - Boston's NPR news station
Top Stories:
PLEDGE NOW
‘Time Warped’: The Many Ways Humans Experience Time

This program is rebroadcast from May 28, 2013.

Time flies. Time stands still. We’ll look at time and human perception.

(elisafranca/Flickr)

(elisafranca/Flickr)

Time is weirdly elastic. Physics and philosophy have their explanations, but every human knows it’s true. Time stands still, we say. Time flies. A minute can seem an eternity. An hour can go by in a flash. A child’s summer can seem endless. A grandparent’s seasons can go by in a whir. A great athlete may almost see the ball, the racetrack in slow motion. How does that all work?  My guest today says the experience of time is actively created by our minds. This hour On Point: We are off the clock today, out where time is malleable. We’re looking at human perceptions of time.

– Tom Ashbrook

Guests

Claudia Hammond, author of “Time Warped: Unlocking The Mysteries Of Time Perception” and host of “All In The Mind” and “Mind Changers” on the BBC. (@claudiahammond)

Robert Sabbag, author of “Down Around Midnight: A Memoir Of Crash And Survival.”

From Tom’s Reading List

Scientific American: Time On The Brain: How You Are Always Living In The Past, And Other Quirks Of Perception – “The bottom line is that memory is essential to constructing scenarios for ourselves in the future. Anecdotal evidence backs this up. Our ability to project forward and to recollect the past both develop around age 5, and people who are good at remembering also report having vivid thoughts about the future.”

Smithsonian: Do Humans Have A Biological Stopwatch? – “When we witness the passage of time, according to noted physicist Paul Davies, we are actually observing how the “later states of the world differ from earlier states that we still remember.” In that sense time is like a movie: We are seeing slightly altered images playing in rapid succession.”

io9: How Do You Really Know What Time Is? – “The scientists who work on the problem of time in the brain sometimes refer to their area of expertise as “time perception” or “clock timing.” What they’ve discovered is that your brain is one of the least accurate time measurement devices you’ll ever use. And it’s also the most powerful.”

Read An Excerpt From Claudia Hammond’s “Time Warped”

From the book TIME WARPED by Claudia Hammond. Copyright © 2013 by Claudia Hammond. Reprinted courtesy of Harper Perennial, an imprint of HarperCollins Publishers.

“Your Time Is My Time” (from Chapter One: The Time Illusion)

(Courtesy of HarperCollins Publishers)

(Courtesy of HarperCollins Publishers)

Each society forms rules about time that its people share and understand. In many parts of the world, including Europe and the US, if a ticket for a play says 7.30 p.m. it is customary to arrive earlier than the specified time, but if a party invitation says 7.30 p.m. you are expected to arrive later. The sociologist Eviatar Zerubavel believes that these social rules provide us with a means of judging time. We learn to expect a play or show to last about two hours and anything longer starts to feel as though it is dragging, whereas the same period of time would feel too short to count as a morning’s work. If we unexpectedly see someone at the wrong time we might not even recognise them. Cultures develop shared ideas of appropriate timings; how long you should stay when invited into someone’s home, even how long you should know a partner before you consider marrying them. Exceptions surprise us. I remember sitting at a lunch in Ghana on a table with six men, two of whom (one local and one from Scotland) surprised the rest of us with their tales of marriage proposals on first dates. (In case you are wondering, both the women they asked said ‘Yes’, and both marriages are still going strong more than two decades later.)

Routines give us a sense of security. They are so important that the mere act of breaking them can disrupt a person’s concept of time and, in extreme cases, even cause terror. At Guantanamo Bay it was standard practice to make the timing of meals, sleep and interrogation unpredictable, defeating a prisoner’s urge to count time and thereby inducing anxiety. Knowing the exact date was of no practical use to Alan Johnston, yet he knew he needed to try to keep track of the calendar. This desire for predictability and control is nothing new. In the early Middle Ages, Benedictine monks decided that predictability was essential to living a good and godly life and would ring bells at fixed intervals and carry out regular services to create a shared routine.

Time dictates the pattern of our lives — when we work, when we eat, even when we choose to celebrate. Just as the Benedictine monks knew when to expect the bells to ring, we each form appropriate temporal schemata for our own lives, which overwrite each other as they go out of date. (As soon as you have a new school timetable, it’s very hard to remember the previous one.) Some of our temporal schemata are controlled by the changing patterns in the seasons, so inevitably winter and summer are particularly salient time-frames. Others are defined by our culture, so if I were to be dropped in my street at a random time and asked to guess the time, the day of the week and the month, then a combination of nature and culture would provide external cues to all three; if there is little traffic, few people walking by and no sign of life in the barber’s, then it must be a Sunday. The temperature and the presence or absence of leaves on the sycamore trees will give a clue as to the time of year, and if the sun is out, its position in the sky would give a rough indication of the time of day.

The cyclical nature of the calendar helps us to organize time in our minds. When you are at school, the academic timetable punctuates the year, a punctuation that can have a lasting emotional impact (from which some teachers never escape). The American psychiatrist John Sharp has noticed that a number of his clients feel worse at the end of the summer — a hangover from years of back-to-school dread. Surprisingly, in the temperate climates in the northern hemisphere suicide rates are higher in the spring, as though deep despair sets in when the promise of spring fails to deliver respite from a spell of misery.

Claudia Hammond, author of "Time Warped." ( Ian Skelton/HarperCollins Publishers)

Claudia Hammond, author of “Time Warped.” (Ian Skelton/HarperCollins Publishers)

As you’d expect, the effect of the seasons varies depending on where you live, as do attitudes towards time. To investigate this the social psychologist Robert Levine compared the tempo of life in 31 countries around the world using three indicators. First, he measured the average walking speed of random pedestrians walking alone in the morning rush hour along a flat street with wide pavements. How fast did people choose to walk? Window-shoppers were excluded on the basis that they dawdle, and the streets selected were not so congested that the crowds would slow people down. Second, he wanted to compare the efficiency of an everyday task, so he measured the time taken to request a stamp in the local language, to pay for it and to receive the change. Finally, to establish the value placed on time-keeping in each culture, the accuracy of 15 clocks on the walls of banks in each city was checked. Combining these measures gave him an overall score for pace of life. It may not surprise you to learn that the USA, northern Europe and South East Asian countries had the fastest tempos, but Levine’s findings weren’t all so predictable. The efficiency of stamp-selling in Costa Rica brought the country up to thirteenth place in the tempo charts (funnily enough that’s the exact opposite of the experience I had buying a stamp there, but then that’s why we have systematic research on these things, rather than relying on anecdote). Even within the same country the variation can be extreme. On comparing 36 cities in the USA, in this instance combining walking speeds and clock accuracy with the time taken to obtain change in a bank, Boston came out fastest, while the home of showbiz, Los Angeles, was slowest, let down by particularly laid-back bank clerks. Everyone expected New York to come out on top, but in a 90-minute observation period during the early 1990s, the researcher witnessed one pedestrian dealing with a mugger and another with a pickpocket, which might have slowed them down.

At the time of the study the countries with the fastest tempos were also the countries with the strongest economies. This raises the question of which comes first — do people in active economies move faster because time is perceived to be more valuable, or did the fast pace of life lead to economic success? There’s no doubt that energy and speed can help some businesses, but in some cases there is a limit to the extent to which the speed of your work can increase the market for your goods. However fast you make umbrellas, if it never rains where you live, no one will buy them. So the relationship between tempo and gross domestic product is best seen as a two-way interaction. Speed leads to some economic success, but economic success also requires people to move faster and makes a society more reliant on the clock.

Please follow our community rules when engaging in comment discussion on this site.
  • eyean540

    I find that as I grow older a day, a week, a year appears to travel faster. My rationalization of this is that as every increment passes it becomes a smaller portion of the total time that I have been alive, thus perceived as shorter.

  • art525

    I am a painter. One time I was painting in my studio lost in what I was doing, deeply engaged. At some point I felt i little pain in my back. I straightened up and looked at the clock and eight hours had passed. Artists talk about that sensation a lot. It’s often referred to as being in the zone. Tom just mentioned about the slow motion in a car accident. I experienced the same thing- wathcing the shards of glass slowly floating by and I could see the expressions of the faces of the girls in the other car and wathc the growing fear and horro on their faces.

  • Dave Twombly

    Now that I have children, especially an infant, time seems to stand still and speed by at the same moment. A day lasts forever but before you know it the kid is 3 months old, then a year…etc.

  • Elizabeth Gordon

    Interesting about cultures who don’t have words for “yesterday” or “tomorrow.” I wonder what their sense of cause-and-effect is? If they do something today and expect a result tomorrow, how do they communicate this experience if they don’t perceive the “normal” concept of time?

  • Nell Damon Galles

    I also remember a profound experience in which time slowed down. I was 9. My mother, three sisters and I had just arrived at JFK airport to visit my grandparents in Connecticut. As my grandparents walked with us through the JFK parking lot, I looked over at my grandfather and watched him fall backward in slow motion. Time did slow down. I remember his fall being almost graceful and controlled. Then time sped up again with the bustle and chaos of my mother and grandmother running over to him. He died of a massive coronary. While it was happening, I certainly felt detached from the experience. Interesting to hear others’ stories of time shifting during traumatic experiences. Thank you for another thoughtful program.

  • Paula .

    When time stood still:
    Years ago in the early morning hours in a dream state I heard a ‘crack’ and I felt my body leaving the bed as if I was levitating or having an out of body experience which it seemed like an hour then suddenly there was a huge impact as a giant tree fell on the roof above my bed.

  • Carol Chapman

    Many years ago, heading north out of Boston on I93 with a friend, traveling about 60 mph. A motorcyclist is in the passing lane. I see his bike suddenly jackknife. He’s thrown into the air, hits the pavement, bounces, and comes down again.
    Meanwhile time slows. I watch as several lanes of cars, in unison, like a dance line, swerve to the left so that the right hand lane is now in the breakdown lane, all in slow motion. The far left lane is empty of cars. The motorcyclist gets up, walks to the center strip and sits on the traffic barrier, his clothes in shreds, holding his head.

  • JBK007

    Two Time stories. Living as a Peace Corps volunteer, we learn about other cultures’ perception and value of time, and the way they live accordingly.

    1. Malian proverb: “gila takari, faa takatari, faa jaari chumal ngeloba, no neddo foti fuu, mo howrata lamaru bamu” From the beginning of time, to the end, signified by the brand on the camel no matter what you’re worth, you’ll never assist in your father’s baptism.

    2. Malian acronym: West African International Time (W.A.I.T.) ;)

  • Logan Fry

    I don’t know if we are allowed to post links, but if so, here is a very, very old art piece: “art and time”…

    http://www.dmoma.org/lobby/movies/art_time/art_and_time.html

  • Steve Bell

    Does time pass differently in space?

  • JBSpurr

    I’m surprised that the case of artificial altered states of perception have not entered this discussion. My errant youth included two dramatic instances: my first trip on LSD cufinb shi h my sense of time was altogether abolished in the sense that I had no subjective sense of “timeness.” This coordinated with the mystical experience I had at one point in the experience where my mind apprehended the Great All as if from the vantage point of one tiny locus: all space, no time. I was somewhat desperately “seeking” time at one point, and became alarmed at the fact that none of the three clocks I looked at agreed with the others. On another occasion, inhalation of pure nitrous oxide led to a radical slowing down of my time perception, most dramatically manifested in the fact that I could no longer follow the melodic line of the music being played, which I heard as isolated notes with lots of “time” between them.

  • Expanded_Consciousness

    Thanks for the show! Keep doing cutting-edge, philosophical shows.

  • Jasoturner

    I have gone through a couple of really difficult break ups (my fault, I confess) and it was my observation that while we cannot be physically trapped in time, we *can* be emotionally trapped in time – for months or even longer. May not be completely on point, but I always found it kind of interesting.

ONPOINT
TODAY
Sep 18, 2014
Flickr/Steve Rhodes

After a summer of deadly clashes between Gaza and Israel, we talk to Jews on the left and right about the future of liberal Zionism. Some say it’s over.

Sep 18, 2014
(Flickr/AisleTwentytwo)

Billionaires. We’ll look at the super super rich, and their global shaping of our world.

RECENT
SHOWS
Sep 17, 2014
Bob Dylan and Victor Maymudes at "The Castle" in LA before the 1965 world tour. Lisa Law/The Archive Agency)

A new take on the life and music of Bob Dylan, from way inside the Dylan story. “Another Side of Bob Dylan.”

 
Sep 17, 2014
Minnesota Vikings running back Adrian Peterson watches from the sidelines against the Oakland Raiders during the second half of a preseason NFL football game at TCF Bank Stadium in Minneapolis, Friday, Aug. 8, 2014. (AP/Ann Heisenfelt)

The NFL’s Adrian Peterson and the emotional debate underway about how far is too far to go when it comes to disciplining children.

On Point Blog
On Point Blog
Talking Through The Issue Of Corporal Punishment For Kids
Wednesday, Sep 17, 2014

On Point dove into the debate over corporal punishment on Wednesday — as Minnesota Vikings running back Adrian Peterson faces charges in Texas after he allegedly hit his four-year-old son with a switch.

More »
Comment
 
Our Week In The Web: September 12, 2014
Friday, Sep 12, 2014

In which you had varied reactions to the prospect of a robotic spouse.

More »
Comment
 
Beverly Gooden on #WhyIStayed
Friday, Sep 12, 2014

Beverly Gooden — who originated the #WhyIStayed hashtag that has taken off across Twitter — joined us today for our discussion on domestic violence.

More »
1 Comment