90.9 WBUR - Boston's NPR news station
Top Stories:
PLEDGE NOW
Is It Time For A Wealth Tax?

Mitt Romney says he pays a tax rate near 15 percent. Nice, if you can get it. We’ll look at a controversial proposal to tax the super rich on their income and their wealth.

Money (401k/Flickr)

Money (401k/Flickr)

So, Mitt Romney is worth maybe a quarter billion dollars, considers $375,000 in speaking fees a pittance, parks millions in the Cayman Islands, and pays fifteen percent, maybe, on his income – while the average American living much lower on the totem pole pays 25 to 35 percent. Wow.

Not a pretty picture. And then, his plans for the country would further cut taxes for million-plus earners, we’re told, and balloon the national deficit. My guest today says this isn’t working. We need a new way.

This hour, On Point: one conservative’s plan to tax the rich directly on their wealth.

-Tom Ashbrook

Guests

Ronald McKinnon, professor of International Economics, Stanford University. His recent op-ed in the Wall Street Journal January is “The Conservative Case for a Wealth Tax.”

Douglas Holtz-Eakin, president of the American Action Forum, a conservative economic policy think tank. Commissioner on the Congressionally-chartered Financial Crisis Inquiry Commission. From 2001 to 2002 he was chief economist of the President’s Council of Economic Advisers under George W. Bush.

Donald Marron, director, Tax Policy Center, which is a branch of the Urban Institute and the Brookings Institute. Former member of the Council of Economic Advisers under President George W. Bush and a former acting director of the Congressional Budget Office.

Highlights

Presidential candidate Mitt Romney says that his own tax rate is around 15 percent, even though his total worth is estimated at around $250 million. A new tax proposal would lower the nation’s marginal tax rate, while applying an addition tax on so-called “accumulated wealth.”

While income is hard to measure and tax, “you can define wealth quite easily,” said Ronald McKinnon, a professor of International Economics, Stanford University and self-described conservative.

“Republicans all say that they want a flat income tax but have forgotten that you need to raise revenue,’ McKinnon said. His proposed wealth tax – on the top 5 percent of the country’s most-wealthy — would achieve the goal of flattening the marginal income tax rate, while the wealth tax would be seen by the public as fairer than other options.

The wealth tax hasn’t gained much traction – in fact, a McKinnon op-ed in the Wall Street Journal stirred up a hornet’s nest of ire from conservatives. “We’ve had some experience with wealth taxes in the United States – we’ve had an estate tax for many years,” said Douglas Holtz-Eakin, president of the American Action Forum, a conservative economic policy think tank. “There’s a growing body of literature that shows that it is far from a benign instrument of social justice…it inhibits overall wealth creation.”

All the remaining Republican presidential candidates have proposed both cutting and flattening taxes. But those changes would have an immediate and negative impact on the nation’s budget deficit, said Donald Marron, director, Tax Policy Center, which is a branch of the Urban Institute and the Brookings Institute.

Those cuts would have an immediate impact on the nation’s budget deficit, said Marron. Romney’s plan would increase the deficit by between $200 billion and $600 billion in a single year, Marron said. .Tax plans by Gingrich and Santorum would increase the deficit by between $900 billion and $1.3 trillion, depending on how those impacts are calculated, he said.

From Tom’s Reading List

The New York Times “Under growing pressure from rival Republicans to release his tax returns, Mitt Romney said on Tuesday that he paid a tax rate approaching 15 percent on his millions of dollars in annual income but said he would not make public his full return until April.”

Wall Street Journal “Prof. Ronald McKinnon’s suggestion (“The Conservative Case for a Wealth Tax,” op-ed, Jan. 9) that a modest wealth tax can be a conservative policy tool is mistaken. Governments use new tools of taxation to grow spending, the reason conservatives oppose a value-added tax.

Los Angeles Times “President Obama is right to insist on the “Buffett rule”: Millionaires should not be paying income tax at a rate lower than their secretaries’. But correcting this inequity is only a small step toward fairness.”

Please follow our community rules when engaging in comment discussion on this site.
ONPOINT
TODAY
Oct 1, 2014
Pro-democracy protesters hold umbrellas under heavy rain in a main street near the government headquarters in Hong Kong late Tuesday, Sept. 30, 2014. The protesters demanded that Hong Kong's top leader meet with them on Tuesday and threatened wider actions if he did not, after he said China would not budge in its decision to limit voting reforms in the Asian financial hub. (AP)

China, democracy and Hong Kong. They’re in the streets in Hong Kong with their “Umbrella Revolution.” What now?

Oct 1, 2014
Actress Eva Longoria, center, Henry R. Munoz III, co-founder of the Latino Victory Project, left, and Rep. Joaquin Castro, D-Texas, are seated at an event launching The Latino Victory Project, a Latino political action committee, at the National Press Club in Washington, Monday, May 5, 2014. (AP)

Latino America. It is very large and growing very fast. How will it move the country?

RECENT
SHOWS
Sep 30, 2014
In this Jan. 15, 2013, photo, Rosser Pryor, Co-owner and President of Factory Automation Systems, examines a new high-performance industrial robot at the company's Atlanta facility.  (AP)

Nicholas Carr says automation, all over, is turning us into zombies. Out of touch with the world. He’s with us.

 
Sep 30, 2014
St. Louis county police officers advance on protestors trying to shut down Interstate 70 in Berkeley, Mo. on Wednesday, Sept. 10, 2014 near the St. Louis suburb of Ferguson, Mo. where Michael Brown, an unarmed, black 18-year old was shot and killed by a white police officer on Aug. 9. (AP)

Police shootings, cop culture, body cameras. And the big debate over how to protect the public and the police.

On Point Blog
On Point Blog
Transcript: Peter Thiel Wants Us All To Go From ‘Zero To One’
Tuesday, Sep 30, 2014

Entrepreneur Peter Thiel on innovation, technological failure and humanity’s uncertain future.

More »
Comment
 
Transcript: Sexual Violence Under ISIS Control
Tuesday, Sep 30, 2014

A transcript from our September 25, 2014 conversation on the Islamic State and sexual violence.

More »
Comment
 
Our Week In The Web: September 26, 2014
Friday, Sep 26, 2014

All of you love to listen to old broadcasts when we play them, and Taylor Swift loves the Internet.

More »
Comment