Vasco da Gama’s Historic Voyage

The amazing voyages of Vasco da Gama. The man who found the Indies when Columbus did not and brought Europe face-to-face again with Islam.

"A chegada de Vasco da Gama a Calicute em 1498," by Alfredo Roque Gameiro (1864-1935).

"A chegada de Vasco da Gama a Calicute em 1498," by Alfredo Roque Gameiro (1864-1935).

Christopher Columbus sailed west, looking for the Indies. Vasco da Gama sailed south and east. Da Gama found what they were looking for.

Around the tip of Africa, across the Indian Ocean, the Arabian Sea. India. And much more. A new history takes the pittance we learn in grade school and gives us the whole, amazing saga of Vasco da Gama.

The ships, the voyages, the mystery, the confusing Hindus for Christians. The ambition and glory and cruelty. The face-to-face meeting, again, with Islam.

This hour On Point: the epic voyages and long echoes of Vasco da Gama.

-Tom Ashbrook

Guests

Nigel Cliff, author of Holy War: How Vasco da Gama’s Epic Voyages Turned the Tide in a Centuries-Old Clash of Civilizations.

From Tom’s Reading List

The New York Times “He possessed a visionary cast of mind bordering on derangement; he saw himself spearheading a holy war to topple Islam, recover Jerusalem from “the infidels” and establish himself as the “King of Jerusalem.” ”

Excerpt

P r o l o g u e

The light was fading when the three strange ships appeared off the coast of India, but the fishermen on the shore could still make out their shapes. The two biggest were fat-bellied as whales, with bulging sides that swept up to support sturdy wooden towers in the bows and stern. The wooden hulls were weathered a streaky gray, and long iron guns poked over the sides, like the barbels on a monstrous catfish. Huge square sails billowed toward the darkening sky, each vaster than the last and each surmounted by a bonnetshaped topsail that made the whole rig resemble a family of ghostly giants. There was something at once thrillingly modern and hulkingly primeval about these alien arrivals, but for sure nothing like them had been seen before.

The alarm was raised on the beach, and groups of men dragged four long, narrow boats into the water. As they rowed closer they could see that great crimson crosses were emblazoned on every stretch of canvas.

“What nation are you from?” the Indians’ leader shouted when they were under the side of the nearest ship.

“We are from Portugal,” one of the sailors called back.

Both spoke in Arabic, the language of international trade. The visitors, though, had the advantage over their hosts. The Indians had never heard of Portugal, a sliver of a country on the far western fringe of Europe. The Portuguese certainly knew about India, and to reach it they had embarked on the longest and most dangerous voyage known to history.

The year was 1498. Ten months earlier, the little fleet had set sail from Lisbon, the Portuguese capital, on a mission to change the world. The 170 men on board carried instructions to open a sea route from Europe to Asia, to unlock the age-old secrets of the spice trade, and to locate a long-lost Christian king who ruled over a magical Eastern realm. Behind that catalog of improbability lay a truly apocalyptic agenda: to link up with the Eastern Christians, deal a crushing blow to the power of Islam, and prepare the way for the conquest of Jerusalem, the holiest city in the world. Even that was not the ultimate end—but if they succeeded it would be the beginning of the end, the clarion call for the Second Coming and the Last Judgment that would surely follow.

Time would tell whether this quest for the Promised Land would end at anything more than a castle in the air. For now, bare survival was uppermost in the crews’ minds. The men who had signed up to sail off the edge of the known world were an odd assortment. Among them were hardened adventurers, chivalric knights, African slaves, bookish scribes, and convicts working off their sentences. Already they had rubbed uncomfortably close against each other for 317 days. As they swept in a great arc around the Atlantic, they had seen nothing but the bounding main for months on end. When they finally reached the southern tip of Africa they had been shot at, ambushed, and boarded in the dead of night. They had run out of food and water, and they had been ravaged by mystifying diseases. They had wrestled with heavy currents and storms that battered their ships and tattered their sails. They were assured they were doing God’s work and that, in return, their sins would be wiped clean. Yet even the most seasoned mariner’s skin crawled with morbid superstitions and forebodings of doom. Death, they knew, was just a swollen gum or an unseen reef away, and death was not the worst conceivable fate. As they slept under unknown stars and plunged into uncharted waters that mapmakers enlivened with toothy sea monsters, it was not their lives they feared to lose but their very souls.

To the watching Indians, the newcomers, with their long, filthy hair and their bronzed, unwashed faces, looked like the rougher species of sea dog. Their scruples were soon overcome when they found they could sell the strangers cucumbers and coconuts at handsome prices, and the next day the four boats returned to lead the fleet into port.
It was a moment to make the most stoic seaman stand and gape.

For Christians, the East was the wellspring of the world. The Bible was its history book, Jerusalem its capital of faith suspended between heaven and earth, and the Garden of Eden—which was firmly believed to be flowering somewhere in Asia—its fount of marvels. Its palaces were reportedly roofed with gold, while fireproof salamanders, self-immolating phoenixes, and solitary unicorns roamed its forests. Precious stones floated down its rivers, and rare spices that cured any ailment dropped from its trees. People with dog’s heads ambled by, while others hopped past on their single leg or sat down and used their single giant foot as a sunshade. Diamonds littered its gorges, where they were guarded by snakes and could be retrieved only by vultures. Mortal dangers lurked everywhere, which put the glittering treasures all the more tantalizingly out of reach.

At least so they said: no one knew for sure. For centuries Islam had all but blocked Europe’s access to the East; for centuries a heady mix of rumor and fable had swirled in place of sober fact. Many had died to discover the truth, and now the moment was suddenly at hand. The mighty port of Calicut, an international emporium bursting with oriental riches, the hub of the busiest trade network in the world, sprawled in front of the sailors’ eyes.

There was no rush to be the first ashore. The anticipation—or the apprehension—was too much. In the end, the task was given to one of the men who had been taken on board to do the dangerous work.

The first European to sail all the way to India and step on its shores was a convicted criminal.

From HOLY WAR by Nigel Cliff. Copyright © 2011 by Nigel Cliff. Reprinted courtesy of Harper, an imprint of HarperCollins Publishers.

 
  • Jack Marshak

    “he saw himself spearheading a holy war to topple Islam”

    Put me down as a fan of Vasco da Gama.

    • Heaviest Cat

      Jack, that remark is all I know about you. UNless I’m missing the joke, maybe you and bin laden with his medieval mentality should get a room.

  • Anonymous

    It’s interesting to see the power of myths and how that plays out today.  From the above passage, the Christians viewed the East as an Arab paradise back then.  And today, the same narrative is used -for good or bad- to “explain” why the Muslim world hates the West today b/c of their fall from the prominence they held during da Gama’s voyage.  That latter reason is something I’ve heard many times on t.v. and even on NPR. In fact we can almost think of our own invasion into Iraq and Afghanistan as having the same destructive motive that da Gama had back then!

    Who knows how the narrative will continue given the state of flux in the middle east?  After it all settles, maybe we will see inter-continental pipelines and railroads stretching from China to India to Morocco bringing goods like Marco-Polo?   Then maybe we will have another chapter of trade and commerce with the re-emergence of an Arab Paradise.

    Quite an exciting time.

  • Peace

    Jack, your comment is insulting to people of the Muslim faith. How would you feel if someone said that about you and your faith?  Do unto others as you would have them do unto you, Jack. 

    • Sonya

      Uh. The Christians were already in India. The Mar Tomas Christians, in the area of Kirala, began their churches with the voyage of the Apostle Thomas, who came from Jerusalem on his mission to spread the gospel while other Apostles went to Rome and elsewhere. The Portuguese were surprised to find Indian Christians already practicing their religion there, which they continue to do this day. Jewish traders had already be in the area for many years, and St. Thomas came on those routes.

      • Guest-22

        Please discuss whether Vasco da Gama was a Jewish man, Gaspar da Gama, forced to convert during the Inquisition, which was going on at that time, and pressed into service under a Christian Admiral.  Jews fled Spain into Portugal, no?

        • Tina

          FYI, though not a direct answer to your question:   the Portuguese king who wanted to marry the daughter of Ferdinand and Isabella encouraged some Sephardic Jews to convert (the Conversos) and/or to go out to the recently discovered Azorean islands, because F&I were going to force him to expel (or worse) the Jews of Portugal as a condition of his marrying their daughter.  Portugal needed to populate these islands (otherwise empty of people) so that supplies could be grown there and then picked up later to lengthen the voyages that were already going farther thanks to the development of the caravel ship.  That king of Portugal also courted new residents for the Azores from Holland, due to the mercantile experience of many residents there.  I do NOT know whether Judaism was secretly practiced once the individuals and families arrived in the Azores; if it was, I do not know for how long and/or if there were/is a continuous, secret practice of Judaism in the Azores dating from that time (I am not referring to any later practice of Judaism from any time where lives were not be at stake for Jewish practices and beliefs — does anyone else know?  Thanks!).  I received my information from a college professor of Azorean heritage whose special research interest has been, for decades, the Azorean people.  

  • Anonymous

    I hope you’ll at least play a minute or so of South African musician Hugh Maskela’s great song “Vasco de Gama” – it offers a pretty trenchant commentary about how black South Africans view the impact of white “exploration” and colonization, and de Gama’s centuries-long legacy.

  • AC

    i may have missed this – who funded him?

    • http://gregorycamp.wordpress.com/ Greg Camp

      King John II of Portugal, if I recall correctly

    • Sam

      Many of the investors were Jewish merchants (and expert mapmakers) who were forced to convert–at least nominally–to Christianity. When they were ousted from Spain, they fled to Portugal, and after that, they went to Amsterdam (by the 1600s) and were helping to fund the voyages to America by what became the British East India Company. The interplay of religions and funding, exploration and conquest, must not be limited to just Muslims and Christians. The Muslims in Spain had benefited greatly from their 700 years of relative tolerance of both the Christian and the Jewish religions, a peaceful co-existence that the children of the One God should be striving for today.

  • Roxtepe

    My father’s family has a story passed down about Vasco da Gama.  The story goes that at one point there was trouble in Portugal and Vasco da Gama sought refuge in Bohemia.  Our relative was working as a royal cook, met Vasco da Gama, and married him.  My father’s mother’s last name was Waska (pronounced Vasca).
      Have you come across anything that might shed any light on this?
    Thank you

  • Efrazey

    While working in Singapore a few years ago, I met an Indian man with an English first name and a Portuguese last name, who lived in Malaysia, and worked in Singapore.  I asked him how this came to be and he told me about his father’s city of Goa and how the Portuguese were given an island on which to settle.  His father was enticed to Singapore to work for the British, and they eventually settled across the straits in Malaysia.  He spun a great tale, and by the end of it, most of the office was engrossed.  This seems to be the big-picture part of that tale. 

    I think he said the Indian local head-guy was trying to keep the Portuguese away from his people to avoid disease and other things that sailors are known for.

  • http://gregorycamp.wordpress.com/ Greg Camp

    Before we attack da Gama to harshly, do acknowledge that everyone behaved the same way then.  African kingdoms sold slaves; the Ottomans were pushing into Europe, etc.

  • Mike D

    Mr. Cliff states he offers no apologies for da Gama’s mass murder of women and children, yet immediately does so by saying he “had his orders.”  Classic defense of people who commit atrocities.

    • http://gregorycamp.wordpress.com/ Greg Camp

      But was he exceptional?  It’s not as though there were enlightened societies that got rolled over by European barbarians.  The whole world behaved largely the same way.  It’s unfair to apply our modern standards to people from long ago.  Without those people, we wouldn’t be here, and we wouldn’t have had the chance to develop our standards.

      • Heaviest Cat

        sorry Greg but that justifies nothing. Apparently the Portuguese explorers ignored the words of their professed savior

        • http://gregorycamp.wordpress.com/ Greg Camp

          The mediaeval interpretation of Christianity is sigificantly different from the modern view that some hold.  Jesus was seen as a warrior prince.  Recall that Jesus is quoted as saying, “I come not to bring peace, but a sword.”

          • Heaviest Cat

            ok ,Greg I can see where that could be interpreted to justify violence but mass killing can never be justified by any alleged “standard of the times”. By that logic 500 years from now some historians may attempt to justify Hitler’s crimes by claimiong that anti-Semitism was  just “part of erman-Austrian culture” at the time. 

    • Heaviest Cat

      good point, Mike D. It’s in keeping with Noam Chomsky’s idea that as long as they’re OUR  mass murderers. we never question their actions. I.E. Suharto, Saddam Hussein, Pinochet et al. amazing what history t

  • Tina

    THANK YOU for this wonderfully informative, richly descriptive show!!!! I have been fascinated by the “Age of Discovery” since Social Studies classes in the Third Grade, and even earlier, thru my father’s old, pictorial encyclopedias called “Lands and Peoples”.  I LOVE listening to how the new scholarship expands our understanding of these supposedly “distant” times and lands and issues, especially because the Western cant is gone, and/or seen in context.  Thank you!

  • Errol Lincoln Uys

    And let’s not forget about another “discovery” related to Vasco da Gama’s voyages:

    Two years after da Gama reached India, Pedro Alvares Cabral, commander of the second Indies fleet, followed da Gama’s instructions to steer a course southwest of the Cape Verdes to find good winds to carry his ships past the tip of Africa.

    Cabral steered too far to the west making an unexpected landfall at Terra de Santa Cruz on April 22, 1500 — the land we know as Brazil.

    http://erroluys.com/BrazilPage1.htm

  • Ellen Dibble

    From Eric Ormsby’s review in the New York Times:
     “Though there was longstanding mutual detestation between Christians and Muslims, the real antagonism seems to have been mercantile. There was no “clash of civilizations” to speak of. The Portuguese gazed in covetous admiration at the trappings of the Muslim courts they visited, and Muslims showed no interest whatsoever in European culture (which they considered pitifully inferior to their own). When they clashed, they did so over lucrative trade routes and territorial hegemony; each was quite proudly ignorant of the other’s creed.”

  • Tina

    The guest said that the Europeans had better ships.  Were those the caravels?  Or, did the caravels just get things started?   Thanks!

    • http://gregorycamp.wordpress.com/ Greg Camp

      Caravels, carracks, etc., depending on the configuration of sails.  The galleons came about a hundred years later.

      • Tina

        Thank you!

    • Nikhil

      On a side note: I wonder if the word caravan and caravels come from the Arabic & Hindi word “carva” which means a large group of people traveling together, that is how they traveled to better defend on journey.

  • Loring Palmer [Mr.]

    “If you kill one person it’s called murder.  If you kill a million, it’s called foreign policy.”  This quote was offered recently by Sen. Mike Gravel [sp?], at the Toronto 9/11 hearings.  Sounds like not much has changed in our attitude about “thou shalt not kill.”

    • Heaviest Cat

       Indeed, Loring. Also, notice how ptitifully little coverage ,Mike gravel got on “public” radio during the Democractice primaries? ONly one mention and that was a news item that reproted a millionaires’ willigness to fund his campign.

  • http://gregorycamp.wordpress.com/ Greg Camp

    Oh, here we go–Gavin Menzies and all that rot.  Historians have shown that Menzies is a slovenly researcher.  He’s basically a fantasy novelist.

  • http://gregorycamp.wordpress.com/ Greg Camp

    Caller,

    The Arabs had lateen sails–they had been used in the Mediterranean for centuries.

  • http://gregorycamp.wordpress.com/ Greg Camp

    Do we like the modern world in which the Western idea of individual liberties and rights is fundamental to how our societies are organized?
    If so, we owe a debt of gratitude to these explorers and adventurers who made this possible.

    • Heaviest Cat

      Sure, Greg; ‘individual liberties and rights” if you’re white.

      • http://gregorycamp.wordpress.com/ Greg Camp

        Are you telling me that we’ve made no progress?  Must we reach perfection before you’ll celebrate what we have?

        • Heaviest Cat

          well, no Greg but  how de gama didn’t care about “progress” Those explorers were about subjugation of “heathens’ and gold. History has shown that progress comes from the bottom up. the liberties ,we enjoy were not bestowed upon us by wise old fathers or conquistadors. people had to fight for them.

  • Adilson Barros

    This Portuguese eastward expansion that Vasco Da gama he is known for can be used today as an example to any rising super power of what acquiring to much land means to your culture. Vasco da Gama voyage overshadow important ones ( like Diego Gomes -discoverer of Cape verde Island ) that serves as a platform to launch an agressive discovering period for the portugues people. However, I believe is this over expansion that contribute to the fabric of our current portugal. Some say is the mismanaging of what they acquired from those land. I say simply they forgot about portugal and drive into other people land to concquer. This drive turn portugal into an agrarian society for the next 500 years. 

                                                        Adilson Barros, Boston

    • http://gregorycamp.wordpress.com/ Greg Camp

      In Spain, it was hyperinflation in an economy flooded with gold and silver and a lack of diversity in production.  Was the same happening in Portugal?

  • Errol Lincoln Uys

    Here’s a simple way of looking at what da Gama’s discovery of the sea route to the Indies meant to Portugal and Europe.  (A small excerpt from my historical novel, Brazil.):

    From a friend of his father’s, an old Jew named Isaac Cardoso, Cavalcanti had learned just how grand such profits were even before he himself went to the East. It was a simple lesson, never forgotten.

    He could see the two of them now, sitting on a bench outside his father’s counting-house, in the time the first reat fleet sent to India, that of Pedro Álvares Cabral, had returned.

    Isaac was holding a stick of cinnamon in one hand, a sharp knife in the other. He cut off a small piece. “This,” he said, “goes to the man who took it to Calicut.” He cut off another. “This is for the Arab whose dhow will carry it to Jidda on the Red Sea; this, for the captain of the foist that will land it at Suez.

    “Here are the dues to be paid at Suez, and this for the caravan master bound for Cairo. Now the boatman of the Nile wants his piece,
    and here is payment for the camel carrier to Alexandria.” The little pile of cuttings grew. “Alexandria’s Moor de­mands this for moving cargo in his port; here is Venice’s price for the cost of her gal­ley and the profits of her merchant. And these are the bribes to be passed out along the way.”

    Isaac had whittled the cinnamon until a small fragment lay in the palm of his hand. “From this must come the profit of the palace and
    merchants of Portugal,” he said.

    Then he took up a second cinnamon stick, the same length as the original, and cut off slightly more than a third of it. “This is what it cost for Cabral to bring this cinnamon home,” he said. “The rest is for our king.”

    http://erroluys.com/BrazilPage1.htm

  • Ellen Dibble

    Speaking of  epochal events (weak segue, but), next time you have a science show, consider this:  

    “The NOAA predicted four “extreme” solar emissions which could threaten the planet this decade. Similarly, NASA warned that a peak in the sun’s magnetic energy cycle and the number of sun spots or flares
    around 2013 could enable extremely high radiation levels.”This is a particular problem in the U.S., especially and poses a severe threat especially in the eastern U.S. Several federal government studies suggest that this extreme solar activity and emissions may result in complete blackouts for years in some areas of the nation. Moreover, there may also be disruption of power supply for years, or even decades, as geomagnetic currents attracted by the storm could debilitate the transformers.”Last month, the Nuclear Regulatory Commission said U.S. plants affected by a blackout should be able to cope without electricity for at least eight hours and should have procedures to keep the reactor and spent-fuel pool cool for 72 hours.”From International Business Times, August 8, 2011.

  • Falberto73

    While I still haven’t read the book from the interview there are some aspects that could have been answered with a bot more of detail. The whole story on how the Portuguese ships dominate the indian seas and all the gulf trade, stopping the trade into the Mediterranean to other European cities like Venice was what made Portugal filthy rich at the time. They started controlling all aspects of this trade by controling the cities in the golf. Obviously, this was not the work of Vasco the Gama, he only started the “job” the important man here was Afonso de Albuquerque (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Afonso_de_Albuquerque).

    I like when the author says it was project that took 1000 years to complete. Indeed, and the man and women involved are the one in the Lisbon monument that one of your callers mention. It was all planned in cunning detail by king Joao II, and even before that with king Joao I (3 generations before joao II).

    A small correction during the Al-Andalus period when the Moors (Muslims) was in the Iberian Peninsula there was no Spain, only a collection of christians kingdoms that obey to the king of Leon.

    Cheers Filipe

  • Althea2000

    Too long to read

  • Brucetopping

    Bought this book after hearing this interview.  Found it to be excellent.  Well written and fascinating.

  • Guest

    So it is acceptable for the English to be proud of their colonial past, but the Portuguese and Spanish must be made to feel ashamed of theirs? What a double standard! Why is 15th Century Spain and Portugal always judged under contemporary morality standards? Shouldn’t England, Holland, and France be judged under the same standards? This double standard was created, propagated, and institutionalized by England over 500 years ago in a successful propaganda campaign against Catholic Spain and to hide (divert attention) English crimes against humanity.

    The Spaniards brought Christianity and civilization to the Americas (it wasn’t all about the gold as the Hispanophobes claim). It’s a fact that the English nearly exterminated the Native Americans of the United States and Canada; moreover, the English and Dutch were highly racist and did not allow the mixing of races. If the Spaniards wiped out every single native group in Mexico, Central, and South America as so many ill-educated pundits in the United States claim; then why is there such a huge indigenous and Mestizo population (the vast majority) in Spanish speaking countries compared to the United States and Canada? Can anyone answer this? What about the fact that sadistic Protestant England attempted to exterminate the Catholic Irish and other Celtic people? How the English persecuted Catholics? How the English profiteered at the expense of African slaves? The persecution of Aborigines in Australia? New Zealand? The current situation in the Middle East created by English colonial involvement? Apartheid in South Africa created by Anglo-Dutch racist policies? Should we talk about the exploitation of India and China as well?

  • Morketeclor

    Many marketers are finding that a relatively small investment in some the virginian dvd primary market research can yield great returns on increased sales and customer loyalty CIMARRON STRIP DVD.

  • loe0322
ONPOINT
TODAY
May 16, 2012
Photo Illustration (Alex Kingsbury/WBUR)

Democrats charge Republicans with being prisoners of special interests. A young conservative turns that charge around.

May 16, 2012
Lizz Winstead (credit: Mindy Tucker)

Comedian Lizz Winstead, co-creator of “The Daily Show” is with us, on the truth in humor.

RECENT
SHOWS
May 15, 2012
Time magazine May 21, 2012

A breast-feeding three-year-old – and mom – on the cover of Time Magazine. We’ll talk with the guru of “attachment parenting.”

 
May 15, 2012
People arrive at JPMorgan Chase headquarters in New York Monday, May 14, 2012. JPMorgan, the largest bank in the United States, is seeking to minimize the damage caused by a $2 billion trading loss, disclosed Thursday by CEO Jamie Dimon. (AP)

Two billion dollars lost in a flash by JP Morgan. Is this an argument for the Volcker rule – cracking down on speculative bets by the banks?

On Point Blog
On Point Blog
Literary On Point
Monday, May 14, 2012

Enjoy Toni Morrison? Check out these On Point interviews with…

More »
1 Comment
 
Baby Names
Monday, May 14, 2012

The Social Security Administration released today its top 1,000 baby name list for 2011.

More »
Comment
 
Toni Morrison Stuck In Traffic
Wednesday, May 9, 2012

What happened to Toni Morrison?

More »
5 Comments